Woman in Bay Area police sex scandal is charged with battery in Florida
The woman authorities say is the victim at the center of a sex scandal has been charged with simple battery in Florida following the controversial decision to send her to an out-of-state rehabilitation facility even though she is expected to serve as the key witness in the prosecution of at least seven police officers in the Bay Area.
The woman, whose name The Times is withholding because she is an alleged victim of a sex crime, was originally facing a charge of aggravated battery in the biting of a security guard at a drug rehabilitation facility in Stuart, Fla., according to court records. If convicted, she would have faced up to 15 years in prison.
But Monday, prosecutors decided to charge her with simple misdemeanor battery, dramatically reducing the amount of jail time she could face, according to David Lustgarten, an assistant state’s attorney in Florida’s 19th Judicial Circuit, who is prosecuting the case.
The decision to send the woman out of state for rehabilitation has drawn sharp rebukes from Oakland Mayor Libby Schaaf and Alameda County Dist. Atty. Nancy E. O’Malley, who announced on Friday filed that charges would be filed against seven East Bay law enforcement officers in connection with the scandal.
O’Malley said she was forced to delay the filing of formal charges against the officers because the woman had been moved out of state.
Though his office has been in touch with Alameda County prosecutors, Lustgarten said the decision to file the lesser charge in Florida had nothing to do with the woman’s status as a key witness in California.
“As any prosecutor who charges crime in this country will tell you, you go where the evidence takes you,” he said. “It was not bringing me to believe I would be able to prove aggravated battery beyond a reasonable doubt.”
Lustgarten has extended a plea deal to the woman, but he declined to discuss the terms. Calls seeking comment from the woman’s attorney and a spokeswoman for the Alameda County district attorney’s office were not immediately returned.
The woman, a self-described 19-year-old sex worker from Richmond, made national headlines in June when she claimed in a televised interview to have slept with more than a dozen Oakland police officers. She said some of the sexual encounters happened when she was too young to consent, and she accused officers of trading information about planned prostitution raids for sexual favors.
The scandal soon widened, and accusations were also made against several other East Bay law enforcement agencies, including the Richmond and Livermore police departments and the Contra Costa County and Alameda County sheriff’s departments.
On Friday, O’Malley announced her intent to charge five current and former Oakland police officers with a wide array of criminal charges in connection with the woman’s claims. A Livermore police officer and a Contra Costa County sheriff’s deputy, both of whom have since resigned from law enforcement, are also expected to face criminal charges.
The charges include failing to report the abuse of a minor and engaging in acts of prostitution. Oakland police Officer Giovani LoVerde and former Contra Costa County Sheriff’s Deputy Ricardo Perez also will be charged with felony oral copulation with a minor, O’Malley said.
O’Malley said her investigation also uncovered sexual contact between the woman and police officers in San Joaquin and Contra Costa counties as well as the city of San Francisco, though she did not have jurisdiction to prosecute there.
A spokesman for the San Joaquin County district attorney’s office has said the agency is investigating allegations of misconduct involving the woman and a law enforcement officer within their jurisdiction.
Contra Costa County prosecutors have already declined to prosecute one Oakland police officer, Terrell Smith, in connection with a sodomy charge related to the woman’s claims.
Doug McMaster, Contra Costa County’s chief assistant district attorney, told The Times last week his office has not received any cases it could prosecute in relation to the scandal. O’Malley said Friday that Smith will face charges of improperly accessing a law enforcement database in Alameda County in connection with the scandal.
The disclosures have caused Oakland to remove three police chiefs, fire four officers and suspend seven others in recent months.
In August, funds from the state’s victim compensation program were used to send the woman to Florida for drug rehabilitation. The move was coordinated by a victim’s advocate employed by the Contra Costa County district attorney’s office who is based at the Richmond Police Department, one of the agencies the woman has made claims against.
Richmond police have repeatedly refused to answer questions about the decision to send the woman to Florida, and a spokeswoman for the victim’s compensation program said she was barred by state law from commenting on the case. McMaster has said there was nothing nefarious about the decision to move her out of state.
Calls to McMaster seeking additional comment were not returned.
While in Florida, the woman was accused of being involved in a violent altercation with several security guards at a drug rehabilitation facility. She bit a guard on Aug. 29, and attempted to solicit sex from Martin County sheriff’s deputies during the course of her arrest, according to a police report.
The decision to send the woman out of state has been heavily criticized, with some in the Bay Area implying a crime had been committed.
“That’s pretty outrageous conduct. That’s a material witness,” said John Burris, the Bay Area civil rights attorney who negotiated the settlement that placed Oakland Police under federal oversight in 2003. “That borders to me on obstruction of justice. I just don’t understand how they could legitimately think that was a proper thing to do.”
Follow @JamesQueallyLAT for crime and police news in California.
ALSO
9/11 memorial on Los Angeles college campus is vandalized
High school drumline coach in Visalia is arrested on suspicion of sexually assaulting a student
UPDATES:
8:20 p.m.: This article has been updated throughout with additional editing and other details.
This article was originally published at 2:25 p.m.
Start your day right
Sign up for Essential California for news, features and recommendations from the L.A. Times and beyond in your inbox six days a week.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.
